This is technical but chemical (my worst subject) instead of electrical or mechanical but here goes as I didn't know where to post it.




 Okay, I have used Thetford and Camco and Walex and a few others and cant say which is best so Im looking for opinions and experience on which DOES THE BEST JOB OF BREAKDOWN AND DECOMPOSITION OF PAPER AND WASTE. I can dry camp 7 days no problem and can push it to 11, but Im "full of it" after that and was wondering how Happy Camper or Rid X or other products may fare. Sure odor control is important, but digesting and breaking down waste is what Im most interested in. Opinions on the best product and why???????? I don't need to necessarily hear about the good or bad of formaldehyde or other products, just what product works best for say a 10 day stretch and Ive never used Happy Camper or Rid X so curious about them....


 John T  Wants to stay a Happy Camper for extended dry camp periods

Tags: Chemical, Toilet

Views: 191

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

We have used Thetford exclusively since our first trailer in 1974.  Whether or not it is the "best" I cannot say, just that we have used it and never had any problems.

my 2 cents. chemical gets divided into 2 groups: formaldehyde based and the other stuff. If you dump into your own septic I would advise you use the other stuff so all the critters that live in your tank continue to do so. I got folks that love the aquakem blue in the gallon...I think they camp a lot...

sorry John....did not read your entire

never sold rid X but some folks swear by happy camper

Ive used aquakem blue for yrs,, originally bought it at Ace hardware and now can be found just about anywhere, and recently I tried rid X and still determining if it helps,, will see as time goes by. I like how it has the measurment lines on the bottle and ya just pour in the recommended amount, (I buy it in the small bottles,, easier to store then the gallon size ).

Calgon water softener. Called geo method, here is link.  Https://

Started using this and even with desert heat no odar, tanks flushes out better and its cheaper. I found at walmart, mix with water and dump in.

Also, since we are on subject, check out Family Cloth system on google. Not saying we use for all jobs, but with 3 women camping it cuts down on amount of paper going in to tank. We keep extra garbage can with removeable liner to put used cloths in. Just throw in wash on return home. Small basket of clean clothes sits ready to use for quick jobs. 

Happy CAMPing!




  •         How To Links 

-Search Good Old RV's

-Start a New Group 

-Roof Repair Photos & Products

-Repair an RV Roof

-Pick Roof Sealer   

-Understanding RV Electrical Systems 

-Get RV Insurance   

-What to Look For When Buying a Used RV

-Jack Installs Fuel Injection in his Dodge 


 Paige's VintageTrailer Art  

 Paige's VintageTrailerFabric

 Artist Roads                                            Sandy's Stained Glass     



If you love classic and vintage RVs then come Join us. Come on in and have some fun. JOIN HERE NOW


Weird air in my fresh water line.

Started by Marshall Stern in RV Repair & Maintence Sep 8.

1977 Terry Travel Trailer Manual

Started by Ina Schuster in RV Repair & Maintence Sep 3.

1988 Mallard Sprinter 1 Reply

Started by John and Gloria in Vintage Campers For Sale. Last reply by John and Gloria Aug 31.



  • Add Videos
  • View All


If you love classic and vintage RVs then come Join us.

 Come on in and have some fun.         JOIN HERE NOW!

 Dedicated to a simpler, more rewarding and fun way of life in a Good Old RV... 

Vintage Travel Trailers, Vintage Campers, Camper Restoration, Bus Conversions, Vintage RV Forums, Old RVs, Tiny Homes, Boondocking


A work of art by member Paige Bridges

Get your Good Old RVs T-Shirt HERE


 Disclaimer - Please Read it

Enjoy this site and use it totally at your own risk.

By using or viewing this site YOU agree to Hold Harmless anyone associated with it including other members. Also, YOU agree that YOU are solely responsible for ANY and ALL actions, results or damages. Members "opinions" are just that and any repair or alteration comments or recommendations are by folks who are not licensed repair  or mechanical professionals. Any repairs or modifications you do totally at YOUR OWN RISK. Use licensed professionals for all work to avoid possible serious injury or damage. Use  banks for purchases.  Have fun!

Copywrite & Trade Mark Registered GoodOldRV© ,GoodOldRVs©,©,©,GoodOldRV.Com©

© 2019   Created by Russ Johnson.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service